On July 8, Nicholas D. Kristof, an op-ed columnist with the New York Times wrote about the best kids" books ever. The books he listed are interesting.
#1 Charlotte's Web--a story of friendship by E. B. White who enjoyed writing about the animals on his farm. It is a must have for a child's library.
#2 The Hardy Boys series--not one I would include, but definitely on a list of "books for boys which most motivated reading ". Captain Underpants and the series of books by Jon Scieszka do the same thing today.
#3 Wind in the Willows--(A British classic, as many on his list were) Although a classic (a book which stays in print for 50+ years), I have never liked the book and find it boring.
#4. Freddy the Pig series (again a British series). About a lazy pig detective. I can't imagine a child reading it today unless it were the only book available.
#5. The Alex Rider series--A thriller series I have never hard of.
#7. Harry Potter series--What can one say here? Highly motivating reading, terrifically imaginative. Must read.
#8. Gentle Ben--friendship between a boy and a bear in the Alaskan wilderness. Dated and probably out of print.
#9. Anne of Green Gables--strong girl character. Although well-written, not read by many girls today. (Again British--or Canadian)
#10. LIttle Lord Fauntleroy--Huh?
#11, On to Oregon--pioneers--written 90 years ago. Another unknown to me.
#12. The Prince and the Pauper. What modern child would pick this up?
#13. Lad, A Dog. A very good dog story, but dated.
So you see this retired children's librarian and former university children's literature teacher thinks his list is too dated and too British. Go Charlotte's Web and Harry Potter! More later.